Dan Gardner's maiden blog entry - the outlook for leveraged loans
So what exactly are leveraged loans? Leveraged loans are floating rate instruments that are issued by companies to finance corporate restructuring, such as leveraged buyouts (LBOs). After an LBO, private equity companies have to issue a large amount of debt to fund the transaction, and this is then placed on the target's balance sheet. A relatively recent example was Malcolm Glazer's takeover of Manchester United in 2005. Following the takeover, Manchester United approached a number of institutions in the City asking if they were interested in buying the loans. As it happened, we decided not to (and that's not just because I'm a Leeds United fan). Other companies to have issued loans include Gala, the AA, Lego and United Biscuits.
Senior leveraged loans occupy the most senior position in the company's capital structure, which means that if the company fails and defaults on its debts, then leveraged loan holders are first in the queue to recover their money. The average recovery rate for a senior loan holder has historically been around 80%, significantly higher than the 40% recovery rates that are typical for the average high yield corporate bond holder in event of default. Even though senior leveraged loans occupy the highest position in a company's capital structure, though, they typically have a credit rating of double-B or single-B, which reflects the sub-investment grade equivalent rating that would apply to the borrowing companies. Typically a European loan might pay investors money market rates plus 2.25% (currently 7.85%) compared with around 7.50% for a high yield bond, so given the lower risk profile for loans, they currently look good value.
Another advantage of leveraged loans is that they are floating rate assets rather than fixed assets. In other words, the income paid from leveraged loans is a fixed basis point payment over a reference interest rate, and so the total income paid duly rises and falls in line with interest rates. Leveraged loans therefore have no duration (or interest rate risk) and are therefore particularly attractive in a rising rate environment.
The surge in LBO issuance over the past few years has inevitably resulted in the rapid growth of the European leveraged loan market. In addition, institutional investors have increasingly been able to gain access to the primary market for loans, and now represent 49% of the market, up from 40% in 2005 and 25% in 2004. Interestingly, we have seen US retail loan funds (known as ‘Prime Rate’ funds) enter the European market, as the US managers have increasingly recognised the relative value offered by European leveraged loans. Hedge funds have also become major players, attracted by the high yields, the floating rate feature and the exceptional risk/return characteristics the asset class has demonstrated.
One market development that we're watching closely is the potential for rising risk within new leveraged loan deals, which has been possible due to the soaring demand for the asset class. Although encouragingly, while average debt/earnings was higher at the end of 2006 than a year earlier (with debt standing at 4.25 times earnings, compared with 4.01x in 2005), there was a gradual fall in leverage within transactions as the year progressed (4.23x at the end of Q4, down from 4.43x in the third quarter). Our analytical vigilance is as important now as it has ever been - but this is a very interesting asset class right now.
The M&G Global Macro Bond Fund
If I want to gain exposure to high yield, or sterling investment grade for example, I'll buy my exposure through our own teams' existing funds, thus gaining instant diversification and access to their stock picking. Otherwise I'll invest directly, adding overlays to express my credit, currency and duration views, and using derivatives where necessary. Where property yields look cheap to bond yields I can take a modest investment into that asset class too - again thanks to the NURS structure. With so many interesting developments coming through in the world of fixed interest at the moment (for some reason bond investors love to innovate) we hope to be able to add more (generally higher yielding) bond instruments to the portfolio over time.
This fund sits in the Global Bond sector of the IMA classification - as such its returns will include a higher degree of currency risk than traditional UK based bond funds. Given that the pound is at pretty much its highest levels in living memory (the Bank's Trade Weighted Index goes back to 1990, we're at new highs now, although we have been a little stronger versus the US dollar in 1992 immediately before we fell out of the ERM). I think it's time to take the view that its likely to revert to mean - and therefore that overseas asset exposure makes sense at the moment.
We'll keep you posted on developments on this fund. Also look out for further updates on Richard Woolnough's specialist M&G Optimal Income Fund.
Housing market : Down down, deeper and down
Then today we had the UK release of what I believe is perhaps the most important UK economic indicator, the number of mortgage approvals. We have discussed mortgage approvals numerous times on this blog (see here for our last comment), but it's worth a brief recap. The housing market is the transmission mechanism for monetary policy - when the housing market is strong, the Bank of England increases interest rates to stop the economy from overheating. Higher interest rates slow the housing market, then consumer spending and economic growth both slow (both with a lag), then inflation falls (with a further lag), and finally unemployment starts rising as companies react to weaker growth by cutting costs. Any predictor of what's happening to the housing market is therefore worth its weight in gold to figuring out what's going to happen to the broader economy.
What does a collapsing housing market mean for the central banks? It means that economic growth is set to fall very sharply. The US Federal Reserve is acutely aware of the risks, as a falling US housing market has always historically resulted in or coincided with recession. The Federal Reserve is being very active in slashing interest rates but the Bank of England has been slower to react, having cut rates only once so far. With UK rates at 5.5%, many rate cuts will surely follow. The Bank of England will not be maintaining the status quo.
Fine wine (and fine art) as an inflation hedge
2005 - £600 (i.e. about £60 a bottle once tax and duty is added)
2004 - £480
2003 - £594
2002 - £498
2001 - £408
2000 - £402
1999 - £402
A rise of nearly 50% over the period, compared with an increase of under 20% in the UK RPI.
Given the tiny size of the Burgundian vineyards (some make just a couple of thousand bottles a year) supply can't rise to meet demand, as it would do in a widget factory. So if you believe that rise of the middle classes and super rich in the emerging economies is a trend that can only continue, buying scarce, trophy wines would seem to be a good long term bet. The problem is that this market - like that for art - is sentiment and confidence driven, and years when growers get too greedy and confidence falls (like the 1997 vintage in Bordeaux) are followed by long hangovers. Art prices are still 5% below their 1990 boom level. You also need to account for the cost of carry - ie the interest foregone on your wine purchase over the holding period of say a decade or two, and storage costs at about £10 a year per case. In contrast to a boring equity however you can always get drunk on the asset if it falls in price.
PS Talking of the finer things in life, I happen to know that a keen reader of this blog (who for obvious reasons needs to remain anonymous) is in the market for a diamond at the moment. Here's the Antwerp Diamond Price Index. The good news is that despite the rise in commodity prices in recent years, 1/2 carat diamond prices are actually 4% lower than they were in 1995.
Re: Fine wine (and fine art) as an inflation hedge
Too much choice?
I watched Prof Schwartz on iTunes as part of the Ted Conference series. This is a series of short presentations by interesting people. You can also watch them online (click here for Prof Schwartz’s presentation) or download to your ipod. Other presenters include Freakonomics author Steven Levitt and Tipping Point author Malcolm Gladwell.
Michael Milken
His talk was on the subject of change and how the world will be different over the coming decades. The main themes were the rise of the BRIC economies and the value of human capital. Both his charitable work and for-profit enterprises are focused on healthcare and education which he believes will be the source of economic growth in the future.
100,000 fixed rate mortgages refix within a month
Not quite a letter - CPI comes in at 3%
Elsewhere, commodity prices are worth a comment. The major commodity indices have fallen back a decent way over the past year (CRB down over 15%), largely driven by the setback in the oil price, but also in some recent falls in metals like copper. All good news for inflation, but while there's good news in these "hard" commodity prices, the "soft" commodities have seen some impressive rises of late. In particular the price of corn has just jumped to a 10 year high (to $4.165 a bushel) on the back of falling stockpiles. Demand from ethanol producers has driven this shortage, and the dramatic rises in corn prices is causing some social unrest in some emerging economies where it's a staple food. Worth watching.
The Beautiful (expensive) Game
The Bank of England has to continue driving rates higher
Personal Inflation Calculator
M&G Optimal Income - one month on
I believe there are likely to be at least two more rate rises in the UK, and the bond portion of Optimal Income has an exceptionally short duration of just 3 years. On top of this, I sold a significant amount of sterling interest rate futures in December and the beginning of January, which has added to performance since launch (particularly yesterday)
With wider powers, I am now able to accurately express my yield curve view for the first time. I believe global investors are being too conservative on their interest rate forecasts and expect short dated bond yields to continue rising as interest rates go up. Long dated bonds should fare much better, thanks to ongoing support from pension funds. In the US and Europe, I have sold short and medium-dated bond futures, and have bought long dated bond futures. In the UK, long dated bond futures do not exist so I have sold 10 year gilt futures and bought 30 year gilts, which still accurately reflects this view.
As for asset allocation, investment grade corporate bonds form just over 50% of the portfolio. High yield bond valuations are not overly enticing on the whole, and high yield forms 30% of the fund. This is only slightly above the 20% minimum that must be held in high yield corporate bonds in order for the Fund to qualify for the IMA UK Other Bond sector.
Equity exposure stands at just over 10%, and I expect to build this up closer to the maximum 20% limit as opportunities become available. Equity markets still look relatively cheap versus bond markets (and very cheap versus high yield bonds). The equity holdings in the fund are all where a company's earnings yield looks very attractive versus that company's bond yield. Equity selection is made in close consultation with M&G's Equity fund managers and analysts, particularly with the Global Equity team.
UK rates up to 5.25% - "the risks to inflation now appear more to the upside"
Default Rates - Where Do We Go From Here?
In my opinion the likelihood is that Moody's will be proved correct. It doesn't take a genius to conclude that the path of least resistance from a 10 year low is higher, but as ever, timing will be key!
The Wizard of Oz
Anyway, for the record the ratio of silver to gold now stands at 49:1 rather than 16:1, the power of paper money seems to have been relatively durable, and the nipper had a nice afternoon out.
German VAT hike, and pay round begins - inflationary impact?
Secondly wages. Germany's most important trade union, IG Metall, believes that its workers have had a raw deal over the past year. There's been a significant increase in productivity, yet wage growth has been modest - in other words German company profits have been boosted at the expense of labour. Probably helps explains the great performance of the DAX in 2006 (up over 20%). Union officials are looking for wage rises of 4% for the economy overall, and up to 7% in highly profitable sectors. "The wage increases have to cover the inflation rate, and the VAT of 19% in January has to be taken into account as well. And beyond that workers want to participate in profit growth" said Juergen Peters, IG Metall chairman.
The market's expectation for Eurozone rates in 2007 is that the ECB will hike once or twice, from 3.5% to 3.75% or 4%. Wage hikes of 7% for significant numbers of German workers would certainly put the upper end of this range at risk.
Inflation - 2006 sector breakdown
- Fuel and Light: up 29.5% from a year earlier. Although crude oil prices were only up 11% over the same period we've experienced significant rises in utility bills.
- Housing: up 6.6%. Driven by higher house prices, higher council taxes, and higher mortgage interest payments. These are excluded from the narrower CPI measure, which in part explains why CPI is lower than RPI. See here for the Office of National Statistics explanation for the differences in the measures.
- Housing Services: up 5.3%. Probably related to the stronger housing market. New migrant workers from the new EU members might put downward pressure on this component as they join the UK labour force?
- Food: up 4.5%. A major component of food prices is the cost of energy. Transportation costs are a big input, and fertilizer is often petrochemical based. Difficult weather conditions have also caused food prices to rise. Seasonal food price rises were extremely strong (+10.7%).
- Tobacco: up 4.1%
Components rising slower than the average
- Leisure Services: up 3.1%
- Personal Goods & Services: up 2.9%
- Alcoholic Drink: up 2.8%
- Catering: up 2.7%
- Travel Costs: up 1.5%. May be upward pressure on this as the result of significant rail fare increases in January. However, demand for air travel may fall as a result of recent travel chaos (terror alerts, fog, baggage problems, potential strike action in Q1), which may lead to some bargain flight deals.
- Household Goods: up 1.4%. The China effect - although less pronounced than in 2005 where we had deflation here.
Components currently in deflation
- Clothing and Footwear: down 0.4%. Again the impact of cheap production in the far east is a major factor, but deflation in this sector is much lower than it used to be. In 2002 this sector saw year on year price falls of 6%. Some very mixed signs from UK retailers over the Xmas period means we need to pay close attention to discounting here.
- Motoring Expenses: down 0.9%
- Leisure Goods: down 1.6%
If you're looking for future bargains, the biggest acceleration in deflationary pressures appear to be in TVs (falling at around 20% pa) and cameras (down around 5% pa).
Technical backdrop for High Yield less favourable in 2007?
JP Morgan calculate that €6.2bn of paper is due to mature in 2007. Currently a further €3.5bn of high yield debt is trading above its call price incentivising companies to repay this debt which suggests €10bn may be repaid to investors. This is significantly less than what we saw in 2006. Clearly there will be further unexpected refinancings though I’d suggest these are unlikely to make up the shortfall. Could a large LBO and subsequent EHY issuance prove to be the straw that breaks the camels back?
Information overload
Pension fund black hole much bigger than previously thought

